Protecting and growing your retirement nest egg is one of your most important financial responsibilities. Ensuring that your nest egg is sufficient to fund your lifestyle in retirement often means putting at least part of it at risk in the stock market.
Unfortunately, too many people are swayed into believing that being a successful stock market investor means you have to actually beat the market. Beating the market is really, really difficult, especially over longer periods of time. It’s a tough job, but why is it so difficult?
Picking outperforming stocks is hard
A recent article from one of our favourite authors and commentators, Larry Swedroe, highlights some data points from studies that indicate why stock pickers might have such a tough time beating the market:
- The Russell 3000 Index of the largest 3000 US stocks delivered an annualized return of 12.8% between 1983 and 2006
- While that’s an impressive return over that period and achievable for anyone investing in a Russell 3000 Index fund (if there was one in 1983!), trying to beat that index by picking stocks would have been a formidable task – here’s why:
- the median annualized stock return was only 5.1% and the average stock actually lost money, -1.1% annually
- 39% of stocks lost money
- half of the stocks that lost money lost at least 75% of their value
- 64% of stocks under-performed the Russell 3000 Index
- just 25% of stocks were responsible for all of the gains.
- only 48% of stocks returned more than one month Treasury bill returns
No wonder it’s so difficult to beat market indices. Outperforming stocks are really hard to find!
Even the pros find it difficult




